Gravitational, Electric and Magnetic Fields Compared

PhysicsElectric & Magnetic FieldsAges 16–17

Use with my class

Three panels side by side: a planet, a charged sphere and a bar magnet, each with field lines and a test object at the same relative distance and angle. Drag the test object or change the distance to compare: g = GM/r² and E = kQ/r² fall with the square of the distance, while the field of a magnet, which always has two poles, falls with the cube of the distance far away. Gravity only attracts; electric and magnetic forces attract or repel. Each reading records the distance and the strength of all three fields.

Lesson: Gravitational, electric and magnetic fields compared: field lines, field strength against distance, attraction and repulsion, no magnetic monopoles

What it shows

A field is the force on one unit of test object: g = F/m for a mass and E = F/q for a charge. A planet and a charged sphere have radial fields, g = GM/r² and E = kQ/r², so twice as far away the field is a quarter as strong. Gravity always attracts, while electric charges attract or repel. A magnet always has a north and a south pole, as there are no magnetic monopoles; its field lines are closed loops, and far away the two poles nearly cancel, so the field falls as 1/r³.

How to use

Drag the test object in any panel, or set Distance n = r/r₀ and Test object angle; all three panels move together. Choose the Body, the Test mass m, the Sphere charge Q, the Test charge q, the Magnet strength and how the Test compass is held. Read g, E, B and the forces, press Record reading, and tick Cut the magnet in half.

Parameters you can change

  • Body Earth, Moon, Mars
  • Test mass m 1–100 kg
  • Sphere charge Q -50–50 nC
  • Test charge q -10–10 nC
  • Magnet strength (magnetic moment) 0.5–5 A·m²
  • Test compass Free to turn, Held against the field
  • Cut the magnet in half
  • Distance n = r/r₀ 1–3 r₀
  • Test object angle -180–180 °

Questions to explore

  1. How much weaker are g and E when the test object is twice as far from the centre?
  2. Why can electric and magnetic forces repel while gravity only attracts?
  3. What do you get when you cut a bar magnet in half, and why?