Substitution vs elimination – SN1, SN2, E1 and E2 competition in haloalkanes
ChemistryOrganic ChemistryAges 16–17
How do you mainly use this simulation?
Use it with your class: students open it from a link or a QR code, with no account needed.
Choose a primary, secondary or tertiary haloalkane, a reagent (strong nucleophile, strong base, bulky base or weak nucleophile), a solvent and a temperature, and see which pathway wins: SN2, SN1, E2 or E1. The simulation shows the product ratio, the carbocation intermediate, the Zaitsev or Hofmann alkene and an animation of each mechanism. A Williamson mode makes ethers from an alkoxide and a haloalkane and cleaves them with HI.
Lesson: Haloalkanes: nucleophilic substitution and elimination (Zaitsev's rule)
What it shows
A haloalkane can react with a nucleophile or base in four ways: SN2 (one step, backside attack), SN1 (via a planar carbocation), E2 (a base removes an anti β-hydrogen) and E1 (a carbocation loses H⁺). The haloalkane, the reagent, the solvent and the temperature decide which wins; a bulky base gives mainly the less substituted Hofmann alkene. The Williamson mode applies the same model to ether synthesis: an alkoxide and a methyl or primary haloalkane give an ether by SN2, while a tertiary haloalkane gives an alkene by E2. Ethers are then cleaved with HI. The percentages show trends, not measured yields.
How to use
Choose the Haloalkane, the Reagent and the Solvent, drag the Temperature slider and watch the bar chart and the graph. Press SN2, SN1, E2 or E1 (or tap a bar) to animate a mechanism. Choose Williamson ether synthesis in the menu next to Reset: in the Make an ether step choose the Alkoxide and the Haloalkane, then press Record; in the Cleave an ether with HI step choose an Ether and watch which C–O bond breaks.
Parameters you can change
- Haloalkane Primary: 1-bromobutane, Secondary: 2-bromobutane, Tertiary: 2-bromo-2-methylbutane
- Reagent CN⁻: strong nucleophile, weak base, OH⁻: strong nucleophile, strong base, (CH₃)₃CO⁻: strong, bulky base, H₂O: weak nucleophile, weak base
- Solvent Water (polar protic), Ethanol (polar protic), DMSO (polar aprotic)
- Temperature 20–100 °C
- Mode Substitution vs elimination, Williamson ether synthesis
- Step Make an ether, Cleave an ether with HI
- Alkoxide Methoxide: CH₃O⁻, Ethoxide: C₂H₅O⁻, tert-Butoxide: (CH₃)₃CO⁻, Phenoxide: C₆H₅O⁻
- Haloalkane (Williamson) Methyl: CH₃Br, Primary: CH₃CH₂Br, Secondary: (CH₃)₂CHBr, Tertiary: (CH₃)₃CBr
- Ether Methoxyethane: CH₃–O–CH₂CH₃, tert-Butyl methyl ether: CH₃–O–C(CH₃)₃, Methoxybenzene: C₆H₅–O–CH₃, Ethoxyethane: C₂H₅–O–C₂H₅
Questions to explore
- Why does 2-bromo-2-methylbutane not react by SN2, even with a strong nucleophile?
- How does replacing OH⁻ with (CH₃)₃CO⁻ change the main alkene from 2-bromobutane, and why?
- Does raising the temperature increase or decrease the share of elimination, and how does entropy explain this?