Benzene – Delocalisation and Electrophilic Substitution

ChemistryOrganic ChemistryAges 16–17

Use with my class

Compare the Kekulé model of benzene with a delocalised π system using enthalpies of hydrogenation (predicted −360, measured −208 kJ/mol), bond lengths and the bromine water test. The mechanism screen animates nitration, bromination and Friedel–Crafts alkylation and acylation with curly arrows: forming the electrophile, the arenium ion intermediate, loss of H⁺ and regeneration of the catalyst, with an energy profile. A third screen compares phenol, methylbenzene, chlorobenzene and nitrobenzene: the resonance structures of the arenium ion show why –OH, –CH₃ and –Cl direct ortho/para and –NO₂ directs meta, with the effect on rate and the isomer ratio.

Lesson: Arenes: the structure of benzene and electrophilic substitution

What it shows

Kekulé proposed alternating single and double bonds in benzene, but the evidence disagrees. Hydrogenating cyclohexene releases 120 kJ/mol, so three C=C bonds should release 360 kJ/mol; benzene releases only about 208 kJ/mol, so it is roughly 150 kJ/mol more stable. All six C–C bonds are 139 pm long, between a single (154 pm) and a double bond (134 pm), and benzene does not decolourise bromine water. Its six π electrons are delocalised over the ring. Benzene therefore reacts by electrophilic substitution, which keeps the delocalised system: the π electrons attack an electrophile, an arenium ion forms, and loss of H⁺ restores the ring. A third screen adds a substituent: the resonance structures of the arenium ion show why –OH, –CH₃ and –Cl direct to the ortho and para positions while –NO₂ directs meta, and how each group changes the rate.

How to use

On the Benzene structure screen, choose a Model and compare the bond lengths. Pick a molecule under Hydrogenation, predict ΔH, then press Add H₂ (measure ΔH) to reveal the measured value. Press Shake with bromine water to compare cyclohexene with benzene. On the Electrophilic substitution screen, choose a Reaction and use Play or Next step to follow the curly arrows and the energy profile. On the Directing effects screen, choose a Substrate and a Reaction, compare the ortho, meta and para buttons, make a prediction, then press Run the reaction to see the rate and the products.

Parameters you can change

  • Screen Benzene structure, Electrophilic substitution, Directing effects
  • Benzene model Kekulé, Resonance (two Kekulé structures), Delocalised π system
  • Molecule hydrogenated Cyclohexene, Cyclohexa-1,3-diene, Benzene
  • Substitution reaction Nitration, Bromination, Friedel–Crafts alkylation, Friedel–Crafts acylation
  • Substrate (directing effects) Phenol, Methylbenzene (toluene), Chlorobenzene, Nitrobenzene
  • Reaction (directing effects) Nitration, Bromination
  • Position attacked ortho, meta, para

Questions to explore

  1. Why is the enthalpy of hydrogenation of benzene much less exothermic than three times that of cyclohexene?
  2. Which evidence shows that all six carbon–carbon bonds in benzene are identical?
  3. Why does benzene react with electrophiles by substitution rather than by addition?
  4. Why does chlorobenzene react more slowly than benzene, yet still give mainly ortho and para products?