Measurement error in repeated length readings

PhysicsMeasurement & UncertaintyAges 15–16Virtual lab

Use with my class

A ruler with an adjustable resolution measures a metal rod repeatedly; each reading appears half a second apart with a zoomed-in view of the scale. Random error scatters the readings around a value, while systematic error shifts the whole cluster away from the true value. The program computes the mean, each reading's absolute deviation, the mean absolute deviation, and adds the instrument error to get the measurement's absolute error, then reports the result as x̄ ± Δx together with the relative error as a percentage. A second screen counts significant figures in instrument readings (leading, captive and trailing zeros, scientific notation, exact numbers) and applies the rules for addition and subtraction (fewest decimal places) and for multiplication and division (fewest significant figures) to density and molar-mass calculations, rounding half to even.

Lesson: Error in measuring a physical quantity

What it shows

No measurement is exact. Random errors scatter repeated readings around a value, so averaging helps; systematic errors, such as a zero-offset ruler, shift every reading and are not removed by repeating. Comparing the mean with the true length separates precision (how closely readings agree) from accuracy (how close they are to the true value). The second screen shows how the digits of a reading carry its uncertainty: which zeros count as significant figures, and why a density or molar mass may keep only as many figures as its least precise reading allows.

How to use

On Precision and accuracy, press Measure N again and compare the mean with the true value, then vary Zero offset, Scatter and the Ruler resolution. On Significant figures, choose a Reading in Counting, pick How many significant figures? and press Check. In Density, Molar mass and Your own calculation, round the calculator value, type it and press Check; each check is recorded in the table.

Parameters you can change

  • Ruler resolution 1 mm (ruler), 0.5 mm, 0.1 mm (caliper)
  • Number of readings 3–20 times
  • True length of the rod 50–200 mm
  • Systematic error (zero-offset ruler) -2–2 mm
  • Random reading fluctuation 0–2 mm
  • Screen Precision and accuracy, Significant figures
  • Significant figures: part Counting, Density, Molar mass, Your own calculation
  • Reading Analytical balance, Top-pan balance, Burette, Measuring cylinder, Thermometer, Mass in a report, Scientific notation (mass), Scientific notation (length), Counted objects, Defined conversion (inch), Your own reading
  • Your own reading
  • Sample iron bolt, copper piece, silver piece, lead weight
  • Balance top-pan (0.01 g), analytical (0.0001 g)
  • Volume measuring cylinder (read to 0.1 mL), beaker (read to 1 mL)
  • Compound H₂O, CO₂, NaCl, H₂SO₄, CaCO₃, C₆H₁₂O₆, FeSO₄, CuSO₄·5H₂O
  • Reading a
  • Operation +, −, ×, ÷
  • Reading b

Questions to explore

  1. Why does taking more readings not remove a systematic error?
  2. How does the instrument error change when the 1 mm ruler is replaced by the 0.1 mm caliper?
  3. How could you detect a zero offset on a ruler before starting to measure?
  4. Why does a better balance not give a more precise density when the volume is read from a beaker?