Site and situation of cities – why some towns grow and others stall

GeographyPopulation & SettlementAges 15–16

Use with my class

Choose where a town begins in an illustrative landscape – a river crossing, a natural harbour, a defensive hill or a route junction – and run the centuries from 1100 to 2020. The site stays the same, but its situation changes: overseas trade, coal and railways, bigger ships, motorways. Points for site and situation set how large the town can grow, and its population is recorded century by century for each site and each change.

Lesson: Site and situation of cities

What it shows

Geographers explain where cities are with two ideas. Site is the place itself: its ground, water supply, defence and room to build. Situation is the place's position relative to other places: rivers and seas used for trade, roads and railways, nearby resources and the region around it. A site stays the same, but its situation changes with technology and trade, so towns that once led can stall. Students run four sites through the centuries and compare their growth.

How to use

Choose a Starting site with its button or by tapping it on the map, then press Run: the years go by and the population is recorded every century. Use Clock speed to go faster. Untick Railway, Coalfield or Motorway, or tick The estuary silts up, then run again and compare the lines on the graph. Jump to year starts a run later.

Parameters you can change

  • Starting site River crossing, Harbour, Defensive hill, Route junction
  • Jump to year 1100–2020
  • Railway (1840)
  • Coalfield (1800–1960)
  • Motorway (1965)
  • The estuary silts up (1500)

Questions to explore

  1. Which starting site grows into the largest city by 2020, and which factors helped it most?
  2. Why did the town on the defensive hill stop growing after the Middle Ages?
  3. How many times larger is the route junction in 1900 with the railway than without it?