Redistricting and gerrymandering – packing, cracking, wasted votes, efficiency gap and compactness
GeographyMaps & MappingAges 15–16
How do you mainly use this simulation?
Use it with your class: students open it from a link or a QR code, with no account needed.
A grid of 81 voters for two parties is split into 9 districts of 9 voters. Draw the districts yourself, or start from columns, rows or squares, and see how the same votes can give very different numbers of seats. Packed and cracked districts are marked, the wasted votes and the efficiency gap are worked out for every map, and the Polsby–Popper compactness of each district is shown. A seats–votes graph compares all the maps you record.
Lesson: Political geography: redistricting, gerrymandering, the efficiency gap and compactness
What it shows
Where each district elects one member, the people who draw the boundaries can change who wins without changing a single vote. Here 81 voters for parties A and B live on a grid, and students draw 9 districts of 9 voters. Packing one party's voters into a few districts and cracking the rest across many lets the smaller party win most of the seats. The efficiency gap compares the votes each party wastes, and Polsby–Popper compactness measures how round each district is. Every recorded map appears on a seats–votes graph.
How to use
Choose Where voters live and Voters for party A. Start from Columns, Rows, Squares or Empty map, pick a number under Paint district, then drag or tap squares to move them into that district. When the status line says the map is valid, read the seats, wasted votes, efficiency gap and compactness, and press Record this map. Show packed and cracked districts marks both tactics on the map.
Parameters you can change
- Where voters live Town and countryside, Mixed, Valley belt
- Voters for party A 30–70 %
- Start from Columns, Rows, Squares, Empty map
Questions to explore
- Why can party A win fewer than half of the seats with compact square districts?
- How many seats can the smaller party win by packing and cracking, and what is the efficiency gap then?
- Can a map be compact and still have a large efficiency gap?