Keystone species – sea otters, urchins and kelp forests, tipping point and recovery

BiologyEcology & EnvironmentAges 17–18

Use with my class

A North Pacific rocky reef where sea otters eat sea urchins and urchins graze kelp. Remove or reintroduce the otters to see urchins boom, the kelp forest collapse suddenly past a tipping point into an urchin barren, and recover when otters return. Winter storms and urchin larvae pulses test how stable the reef is with and without the keystone species, while biomass at each trophic level is shown over time, on a kelp-against-urchins graph and as a biomass pyramid.

Lesson: Keystone species and community stability: two stable states

What it shows

A keystone species has an effect on its community far larger than its biomass. On North Pacific rocky reefs sea otters eat sea urchins, and urchins graze kelp. With otters, urchins stay few and the reef is a kelp forest. Without them, urchins multiply until the forest suddenly collapses into an urchin barren, which then persists while starving urchins graze every new kelp plant. Both states are stable over a wide range of urchin biomass, so recovery needs far fewer urchins than the collapse did. This fitted model follows Estes and Palmisano (1974) and later work on the Aleutian Islands.

How to use

Press Run to follow the reef for 100 years. Use Remove sea otters and Reintroduce sea otters to change the top predator, and Winter storm or Urchin larvae pulse to test its stability. Change Start as and Otter loss to hunting or killer whales, and switch the Graph between Over time, Kelp against urchins and Pyramid. Record adds the current biomasses to the table.

Parameters you can change

  • Start as Kelp forest with otters, Urchin barren without otters
  • Otter loss to hunting or killer whales 0–30 %/yr
  • Graph Over time, Kelp against urchins, Pyramid

Questions to explore

  1. Why does the kelp forest collapse suddenly, years after the otters were removed, rather than declining steadily?
  2. Why does kelp return only when urchins fall far below the biomass at which the forest collapsed?
  3. How does a winter storm affect the reef with and without sea otters, and why?